|
The Traditional Account
Traditionally, the story of the Battle of Kadesh begins with the
army of
Ramesses II advancing upon the city of Kadesh in four corps. Ramesses II himself
was with the lead element of the corps, known as Amun. While crossing the River
Orontes (Arnath) to begin the approach to the city from the south, two Bedouin tribesmen,
secretly in the employ of the Hittite king, led what appears to have been a
gullible Ramesses the Great into believing that the Hittite army was many miles
away to the north. Ramesses II, believing he had stolen a strategic advantage,
having arrived on the battle grounds early, ordered the army of Amun onward
without delay.
However, after making camp to the northwest of Kadesh, Ramesses II was rather
unnerved to discover from captured enemy scouts that the Hittite army had
already arrived. Located behind the Kadesh tell, they were even now ready for
battle. Hearing this news, Ramesses II sent his vizier to the army (really, more
of a division) of Re some miles back to hurry them forward. However, they were
ambushed by 2,500 Hittite chariots as they crossed the plain of Kadesh and so
were overcome. This force then wheeled north and attacked Ramesses II's
encampment, overrunning them as well. Though many of Amun's troops panicked and
abandoned Ramesses to his fate, the Pharaoh donned his armor and from his
chariot, almost single handedly held off the Hittite chariotry inflicting heavy
losses on them. However,
Ramesses II may really have been saved by the vision of
booty within his camp, which seems to have occupied the enemy troops.
Overseeing the battle and observing the fate of his original chariot attack,
the Hittite king ordered a further 1,000 chariots into the battle arena.
However, just as these additional warriors reached the battle front, Ramesses II
was saved by the arrival of the Ne'arin. This was a second body of troops that
Ramesses II had detached from the main campaign and ordered to approach Kadesh
from the north. With the aid of these troops, Ramesses II was able to fend off
the Hittite attack and win the battle, leaving many of the enemy dead on the
battle field and the survivors faced with the humiliation of having to swim back
across the Orontes River to escape the wrath of the Pharaoh.
Some accounts of the battle have the two warring parties facing off once
again the next day, but the ultimate results of the contest was a truce, after
which the Egyptians and Hittites withdrew to their respective homelands (Ramesses II, having crushed his enemies).
The above is basically the Egyptian account of the Battle of Kadesh, and it
probably does provide a framework for the overall action, though over the years,
hardly any detail has escaped the attention of analysts. Though the battle may
indeed be the earliest military action recorded in detail, there are many
specifics that are either missing or are subject to considerable debate. In fact,
Ramesses II certainly presented the battle with an obvious prejudice,
particularly towards his own actions and deeds, but indeed, even the main three
sources that we have of the battle, consisting of a poem, bulletin and reliefs,
even disagree on some of the facts, and the scattered information derived from
Hittite sources only confuse the matter additionally.
Prelude to the Battle of Kadesh
The Battle of Kadesh
fought by Ramesses II was a long time in the
making, and
not the first to be fought between the Hattities and Egyptians over this small,
but strategically located vassal state.
Ramesses II had probably accompanied his
father, Seti I on
one similar campaign prior to his ascending the throne of
Egypt. However, though Seti I may have taken Kadesh, by the time of Ramesses
II's reign, it was back in the hands of the Hattities.
From the onset of Ramesses II's reign, it is apparent that he intended to
renew the struggle for domination in southern Syria, and so almost immediately
he began preparing for the coming hostilities. He added a fourth field army to
his military establishment, and expanded the eastern Delta city of Pi-Ramasses,
his new capital, to act as a staging point for operations in the Levant.
In his fourth year, during the spring of 1301 BC, Ramesses led his army into
southern Syria for the first time as king, reaching as far as Simyra and
succeeding in returning the Amurru kingdom to the Egyptian fold.

Map of the General Region
It soon became evident to the Hittite
king, Muwatallish, that in order to
protect his holdings in Syria, he would have to confront the Egyptians in a
major military campaign. The venue of this coming battle was never in doubt by
either party. They would meet beneath the walls of Kadesh in order to settle
once and for all the future of their respective empires in Syria.
In fact, it is likely that the Hittites and the Egyptians agreed on the
site, as well as the time of battle in advance. Certainly, there is an inference
of this considering that the two sides arrived on the scene of Kadesh at about
the same time during the month of May, 1300 BC. It should be noted however that
this was not an ideal battleground for the Egyptians. The Hittites were
operating in a region that was under their control where their supply lines were
short. They probably staged their campaign out of Carchemish,
not far from Kadesh at all. Furthermore, the city of Kadesh, currently under their command, was large
enough to accommodate the Hittite army should matters go awry. It provided
a good defensive position, surrounded by both a mote and the Orontes River
itself.
Ramesses II would also have to contend with one of the largest armies ever
assembled by the kingdom of Hatti. Though no substantiating sources have ever
been unearthed, Ramesses speaks of the Hittites having eighteen allied and
vassal states providing some 3,700 chariots and 37,000 infantry. We know
that these included Aleppo, Khatti, Naharin, Arzawa, Dardany, Keshkesh, Masa,
Pidassa, Arwen (?), Karkisha, Luke, Carchemish,
Ugarit, Dedy, Nuhashshe,
Mushanet, Kadesh as well as the country of
Kizwadna (Kizzuwadna), whom he
commissioned to:
"...send one hundred horses equipped (with chariots) and a thousand
foot soldiers to the army of the Sun, who will provide for them."
Throughout the months of March and April, Pi-Ramasses
must have been a
beehive of activity, as individual units were mustered into the four field
armies (also sometimes referred to as divisions in some texts). One sign of
times to come was the notable increase in the number of foreign troops in the
regular Egyptian army. These included Nubians,
Sherden,
Libyans and
Canaanites.
The four armies were each made up of about 5,000 troops, for a total of 20,000
combatants. While no mention is actually made of the army's chariot strength, by
this date the Egyptians should have been able to muster a significant
force.
Ramesses left Egypt in April, probably taking the coast road to Gaza. It was
there that Ramesses sent the Ne'arin, probably an elite unit, northward from
Gaza along the coast road to Canaan, probably to secure the loyalty of the
Canaanite coastal cities. On a specific day, they were probably ordered to
arrive at Kadesh by way of the Eleutheros Valley in Amurru. The main body of his
forces followed the route inland through Canaan, traversing the eastern side of
Lake Galilee afterwards entering the Bekaa Valley in order to reach Kumidi.
Ramesses II had arrived near
Kadesh and was encamped with the army of Amun
about one day's march south from Kadesh. The location of their camp has been
identified as a high, conspicuous mound known as Kamuat el-Harmel. We are
actually not certain about the day that Ramesses II arrived at this location,
but rather that he was at the camp on the ninth day of the month of Shemu (late
May). The other three armies, named P'Re (Re), Ptah and Sutekh (Set), lay to the
rear of the army of Amun, each separated by a distance of about 10.5 kilometers
(one iter). While Ramesses II has been criticized for this division of his
forces, it was standard operating procedure to distance the armies in this
manner.
Unfortunately, we have no further specific references to time within the
accounts of the battle, and many military analysts believe that the following
events may have occurred over a broader length of time than what the fluid
accounts of the battle might lead us to believe.
First Encounters with the Enemy
Ramesses II and the Army of Amun began to strike camp on the ninth day in order
to cross the Orontes probably by the ford at Shabtuna (or nearby). It must have
taken some considerable period of time for this to have been effected. Five
thousand men, perhaps along with additional (and probably, considering the retinue
that followed the King, substantial) support personnel, their equipment, including
chariots, had to move down the ridge through the Labwi (Robawi) forest and
ponderously cross the Orontes. This all probably took a great deal of time and
even if the Army of Amun broke camp (a major undertaking in itself) early on the
ninth day, they probably did not complete the crossing until at least mid-afternoon.
Shortly after the crossing, two Shasu Bedouin were encountered and brought
before the pharaoh. It has been generally assumed that they were a deliberate
plant by the Hittite
king to misinform Ramesses II, and indeed, they informed
him that the Hittite army was some distance to the north in the land of Aleppo.
In bronze age encounters, this would have given Ramesses II considerable
advantage. One of the most important aspects of such a battle, after a long
march by opposing armies, was a period of rest and reorganization for battle readiness.
Ramesses obviously took considerable assurance that he was in a superior position
to the Hittite forces, and even the Egyptian accounts of the campaign do not
attempt to hide his gullibility on this matter. However, historians may be too
quick to lay blame on Ramesses II. The king clearly followed normal army
operating procedures, and it was common for a screening force of chariots or
horsemen to move ahead of the marching army. This advanced element was either
absent, or may have shared the overconfidence of the pharaoh, but in any event,
it would not have been the task of the king to oversee every operation of his army,
for he had senior officers for that purpose.
At any rate, the Army of Amun arrived in a somewhat casual manner at their
campsite on the plains of Kadesh,
northwest of the city, perhaps late on the
ninth day, not realizing that the entire Hittite army was camped on the opposite
side of the Kadesh mound. While we do not know the precise location of his camp,
it is likely that he used the same site as that of Seti I
some years before. The
Egyptian's no doubt set up camp with the expectations of an extended stay, for at
the center of the camp they erected a shrine to the god
Amun, together with the
great tent of the pharaoh where
Ramesses II "took his seat on a throne of
gold".
Certainly it seems that if reconnaissance of any manner was ordered
previously it was ineffectual, but now the Egyptian scouts made good by
returning with two prisoners found lurking near the Egyptian camp. Refusing at
first to talk, they were beaten before being dragged before Rameses II. The
historical documents record that:
"Then said His Majesty, 'What are you'? They replied, 'We belong to the
ruler of Hatti! He sent us out to see where Your Majesty was.' Said His Majesty
to them, 'Where is he, the Ruler of Hatti? See, I heard it said that he was in
the land of Aleppo, north of Tunip.' They replied, 'Behold, the Ruler of Hatti
has already come, together with many foreign lands that he brought as
allies...See, they are poised armed and ready to fight behind Old Kadesh?'"
It must have been a great shock to Ramesses II, who, only moments before, had
figured he held an advantage to his adversary, having arrived on the plain of
Kadesh first. As the full implications of this new information sank in, Ramesses
must have understood that he and his army stared absolute disaster in the face.
Not only was the Hittite
army rested and ready for battle, but he had arrived at
Kadesh with only a small part of his overall forces.
A conference was quickly called with his senior staff, where the king
revealed to them their dire predicament. This resulted in the realization that
all would be lost unless their forces could be quickly consolidated, and
therefore, the king's vizier
was quickly sent south in order to implement a
rapid advance by Egypt's other forces. However, at this point the events that
follow become somewhat difficult to recount.
If indeed the Egyptian Army left their camp and crossed the Orontes River on
the ninth day, then it must have been somewhat late that day that the Hittite
scouts were discovered, and even later by the time they were handed over to
Ramesses after being tortured. Some authorities believe therefore that the
vizier would not have reached the closest forces to Ramesses, the Army of Re,
until the morning of the tenth day. However, that army had probably advanced
northward just as the Army of Amun had, camping perhaps in the same location
that the Ramesses II had occupied previous to his crossing of the Orontes.
Hence, it is very possible that the vizier did in fact reach the southern forces
late on the day of the ninth.
The Forces Engage
We know that the Army of Re mustered their forces and, as soon as they could
break camp, attempted to close ranks with the Army of Amun as the vizier
continued south in order to warn Egypt's other forces. Soon the Army of Re was
crossing the River Orontes but
Ramesses II would be disappointed if he expected
their timely
arrival. However, whether this division of the Egyptian army crossed the River
late on the nine day of the month of Shemu or early on the
tenth day is open to speculation. regardless, what transpired
next could not have been as much of a surprise as the ancient
text makes of it.
As the Army of Re crossed the Orontes River, they were set
upon by Hittite
chariotry, who emerged from the tree line to
the right of the column about three quarters of a mile
distant. However, it should be noted that some time must have
elapsed between the dispatch of the vizier and the Army of
Re's crossing of the Orontes. They, along with the Army of
Amun under the direct command of Ramesses, had some period of
time to prepare themselves for the ensuing hostilities, for
it must have taken time for the vizier
to both have reached
and warned the army of Re, as well for that division to have
struck camp and crossed the Orontes.
Yet, this apparently did not prevent the destruction that
followed. Having emerged from their cover the Hittite chariots
crashed into the Army of Re, as they had been trained, causing
widespread havoc. Many, if not most Egyptologists disagree
with Ramesses stated figure of 2,500 chariots, for this would
have been an overwhelming force that, first of all, would have
required a significant time to cross over the Orontes but
having succeeded, could have very likely decimated all of the
Egyptian forces. For this reason, many analysts believe that
the Hittite chariot forces that attacked the Army of Re were
much smaller, perhaps only one fifth of the size documented by
the Egyptians. This could explain much of what happened next.
However, it must also be remembered that by this point, half
of the Egyptian forces, consisting of some ten thousand men,
along with half of the Egyptian chariotry
were now on the plains of Kadesh,
so the force of Hittite chariots may have been substantial
given the initial destruction that was caused. Furthermore,
the Hittite forces may not have had to cross over the Orontes
proper, but rather a fairly small tributary.
Certainly the Hittite chariots scattered the Army of Re,
but probably did not actually decimate it. After crashing
through the ranks of the Egyptian column, they wheeled to the
north following the vanguard of this division as they rushed
to the perceived safety of the Amun lines. The army of Amun
had little time to secure a combat stance, but given the
alarming information provided by the Hittite scouts, they must
have been in a state of readiness to some extent. It is
doubtful that the column of Re, which probably stretched on
for some two and one half miles, was completely overcome by
the Hittite
attack. As the remnants of the Army of Re
approached the camp of Amun, followed in hot pursuit by the
Hittite chariotry, lookouts should have seen the advancing
storm, signaled by the dust plume created by such a
disturbance, and alerted at least some of the camp to the
impending battle.
Nevertheless, the Hittite chariots very quickly crashed
through the front lines of Ramesses II's camp, but were
quickly slowed by the impending obstacles of such a large
camp. Even so, they created widespread panic amongst these
troops as well, scattering the forces as they had evidently
done with the army of Re. Yet, pharaoh had been alerted by
this time to the attack, and in what seems to have been a
rather cool, collected effort on his part, first instructed
his court, which probably included a few princes, on their defense,
and then proceeded to dress himself in armor and prepare his
immediate guard for a battle which he would heroically
lead.
By this time, the Hittite chariotry
forces were
concentrated within the camp and perhaps at a point where they
had become somewhat disorganized. They were probably also in a
position where maneuverability of their much larger chariots
was difficult because of obstacles within the camp. Further, after attacking the
Re column and wheeling northward for the camp of Amun, their
horses must have surely been exhausted. Doubtless, they
had even lost a few of their kind in the running battle that
was even now continuing.
Now, it was Ramesses II who:
":...appeared in glory like his father Montu, he
assumed the accoutrements of battle, and he girded himself
with his corslet"
However, before engaging in the battle, he
sought safety for his family members that traveled with him,
but thereafter, in a fit of valor,
Ramesses II's, together with his
personal guard, attacked the charging Hittite forces and, with
the superior maneuverability of their chariots, wheeled about
in successive attacks on the slower forces of the Hittites.
We are told by Ramesses II that:
"I found the 2,500 chariots, in whose midst I was,
sprawling before my horse. Not one of them found his hand to
fight...and they were unable to shoot. They found not their
hearts to seize their javelins."
The results were that the Egyptians began to pick off the
overextended Hittite chariotry. Of course, the fact that the
Hittite forces could be dealt with at this point by what was
apparently only a fairly small force of Egyptians is another
reason why historians believe that there were less then 2,500
chariots in the Hittite attack. However, Ramesses II
tells us that he:
"caused them to plunge into the water (of the
River Orontes), even as crocodiles plunge, fallen upon their
faces. I killed among them according as I willed".
However, there may have also been a somewhat larger number
of Egyptian forces who stood against the Hittite
forces rather than running in the cowardly manner that the
reliefs depict. It is difficult to imagine, having been warned
of their dire circumstances by the Hittite scouts, that the
Amun camp was not highly alert and that the five thousand
troops of that division were not in a state of battle
readiness. It is more than somewhat likely, given his vanity
on such matters, that Ramesses II empathized his own heroism
on the walls of his temples at the expense of his armed
forces.
Irregardless, the Hittite forces began to lose their
initial advantage. Overlooking the battle scene along with the
nobles and high officials who had accompanied the Hittite
army, Muwatallish monarch appears to have been shaken by the
Egyptian recovery that he witnessed within the running battle
at Ramesses II's camp. In order to save his dwindling forces,
he ordered another thousand
chariots to the attack. This force appears to have consisted
of the high nobles who surrounded the king. However, several
pieces of information should be closely examined at this
point.
First, it is argued that this second force could not have
been as great as one thousand chariots, for the logistics of quickly
sending that large of force immediately into battle would have
been difficult, if not impossible. However, the fact that the
nobility within the Hittite forces were now sent into battle
also suggests that the initial commitment of Hittite chariotry
must have been substantial. Though perhaps not as many as
2,500 chariots, it seems to have left the Hittites with only
the elite nobility in reserve.
Secondly, it has been suggested by highly authoritative
sources that the initial chariot attack was actually
unintentional. Some scholars believe that the Hittite chariots
may have simply been scouting the Egyptian forces, but when
they broke from the scrub trees and saw the Army of Re, they
had little choice other than crashing through the Egyptian
column. These analysts argue that, had the attack been
intentional with a force as large as 2,500 chariots, they
could have and should have completely decimated the Egyptian
forces.
However,
the fact that Muwatallish was in fact observing the battle
with forces ready to reinforce the initial chariot attack,
seems to indicate that the battle was no accident, though many
questions do remain on this matter. For example, during
the entire event, no Hittite
infantry seem to have ever been committed to the battle, which
leaves us with an awkward gap in our understanding of the
battle.
As the Hittite reinforcements entered the fray, the
Egyptian forces must have themselves been exhausted from their
initial encounter with the enemy forces. If they were aware of
the second wave of Hittite chariotry as they charged the camp,
the men surrounding
Ramesses II must have surely felt doomed. However, Ramesses II seems
to have been a lucky man throughout his long life, and now he
was particularly fortuitous. As the Hittite forces approached
the Egyptian camp, suddenly, and seemingly out of nowhere, the
Ne'arin appeared, turning the impending disaster into a route
of the Hittite forces.
It is probable that the Hittites did not know about the Ne'arin. This term
means "young men" and infers that they were perhaps a crack Canaanite
unit who's loyalty to Ramesses II was beyond reproach. It has been suggested
that, rather than an elite unit, this may have actually been
the Army of Set, though the reliefs indicate otherwise. It was
probably no accident that they showed up at this point, though
the exact timing was certainly lucky. These forces had
probably been ordered to join up with the main body of the
Egyptian army on a specific day.
Nevertheless, the Hittite forces were sent scurrying back across the Orontes
river and we are told that many nobles and men of importance within the Hittite
confederation lay dead on the battle field, or were swept away by the river in
their panicked retreat.
The next day, there may have been some additional fighting
according to some accounts, but this may have also referenced
the lashing that Ramesses II would give his troops for their
cowardly actions. In the reliefs documenting the battle,
Ramesses II states that:
"None of you was there...None rose to lend me his
hand in my fight...None of you came later to tell the story
of his heroic deeds in Egypt...The foreigners who saw me,
praise my name to the end of all lands where I was not
known...Since ancient times a man was honored for his
fighting abilities, but I will not reward any of you, as you
have abandoned me when I was alone fighting my
enemies."
It has even been suggested that, even as Muwatallish
overlooked the scene, Ramesses II may have dispatched a number
of his troops to the netherworld.
More importantly, what happened next almost negates the
resounding victory claimed by Ramesses II. He agreed to a
truce with the Hittite
King, who we are told pleaded with Ramesses II stating:
"Suteh are you, Baal himself, your anger burns
like fire in the land of Hatti... our servant speaks to you
and announces that you are the son of Re. He put all the
lands into your had, united as one. The land of Kemi, the
land of Hatti, are at your service. They are under your
feet. Re, your exalted father, gave them to you so you would
rule us. It is good that you should kill your servants?...
Look at what you have done yesterday. You have slaughtered
thousands of your servants....You will not leave any
inheritance. Do not rob yourself of your property, powerful
king. glorious in battle, give us breath in our
nostrils."
Of course, this text obviously offers a view by the
Egyptians. It may be that both parties to the truce realized
that additional battles might have decimated both armies to
the extent that they may ver well have become vulnerable to
other powers within the region. Furthermore, Ramesses II was
obviously facing a crises within the ranks, so we are told
that:
"His Majesty turned back in peace to Egypt,
together with his infantry and his chariotry being with
him"
Ramesses II later signed a peace
treaty with the Hittites which would forever place Kadesh
out of Egyptian hands. From this, it is evident that no real
victory took place, or at least not one that gave Ramesses II
an obvious edge over his enemies. In fact, it would seem that
the Hittites army even shadowed the Egyptian forces as they
headed home.
A drawing of the reliefs at the Temple of Luxor depicting the Battle of Kadesh.
The bottom register shows Ramesses II single-handedly charging
the enemey
Eventually, what
Ramesses II failed to do to the Hittites would be accomplished instead by
the Sea People,
who would infiltrate the Hittite lands and eventually cause that empire to
collapse. But for now, the Hittites were no longer Egypt's great enemy, for
later, Ramesses II would take perhaps several of Hattusilis III's (successor to
Muwatallish) daughters as
his queens and there would be much correspondence between the two courts.
See also:
References:
| Title |
Author |
Date |
Publisher |
Reference
Number |
| Armies of the Pharaohs |
Healy, Mark |
1992 |
Osprey Publishing |
ISBN 1 85532 939 5 |
| Dictionary of Ancient Egypt,
The |
Shaw, Ian; Nicholson, Paul |
1995 |
Harry N. Abrams, Inc.,
Publishers |
ISBN 0-8109-3225-3 |
| Egyptian Warfare and Weapons |
Shaw, Ian |
1991 |
Shire Publications LTD |
ISBN 0 7478 0142 8 |
| History of Ancient Egypt, A |
Grimal, Nicolas |
1988 |
Blackwell |
None Stated |
| Oxford
History of Ancient Egypt, The |
Shaw, Ian |
2000 |
Oxford University Press |
ISBN 0-19-815034-2 |
Archives
|